free geoip What Happened to Dual Sided DVD's? - Jayson's Blog - jaysonKnight.com
jaysonKnight.com
Welcome to my corner of the internet
What Happened to Dual Sided DVD's?

I’ve mentioned before that I don’t really like renting movies; DVD’s are pretty cheap these days so I usually just end up buying whatever I want to watch.  One of the gifts I received this year was a gift card to Blockbuster (a thoughtful gift as I’m a movie buff)…so recently I went to the local store to spend it.  Every single goddamn title I wanted to buy was offered in one format only:  Widescreen.  Ok, so I’ll rent this go round.  Nope, all of those were in widescreen as well.  Bye bye Blockbuster.

Before I purchased my hi-def TV, this wouldn’t have been a problem as Sony DVD players (and probably others) have a setting where you can kind of “stretch” the image vertically if it’s widescreen format to make better utilization of the screen real-estate…it looks a little weird, but is better than having 5+ inches of black space above and below the image IMO.  When I moved to hi-def (and component cable hookups), this is no longer an option, so the widescreen format (although beautiful at 480p or 720i) looks like crap on my 36” 4:3 ratio set.  I paid for the full 36”, and by golly I’d like to put it all of those pixels to good use.

My point is this:  What happened to the dual side DVD format?  When I purchased my first DVD player (‘99 if memory serves), some DVD’s came with both formats on the same disc; one side was standard format, and the other side was widescreen.  I don’t know when they stopped manufacturing discs like this, but I haven’t seen one in quite a while.  It really was a no brainer though and I can’t figure out why they would move away from this.  Perhaps manufacturing costs were too high (though I’d be willing to pay extra to have both formats because at some point in the future I will no doubt purchase a widescreen TV and it’d be great not to have to go out and re-purchase all my DVD’s)?  Who knows, but the other gripe here is why is it so hard to find DVD’s in the standard aspect ratio?  I did notice that Amazon usually sells DVD’s in both formats, so kudos to them…but I still miss my dual sided DVD’s.  I don’t think Blockbuster will be getting much business from me in the future.


Posted Sat, Jan 7 2006 6:58 PM by Jayson Knight
Filed under:

Comments

Brendan wrote re: What Happened to Dual Sided DVD's?
on Sun, Jan 8 2006 4:45 AM
I cannot agree with this at all. One of my pet hates is video played at the wrong aspect ratio, making people look fatter or thinner than they should be. Another pet hate is zoomed images so that the correct aspect ratio is maintained but some of the image is lost so that the remaining image fills the screen. I'll take black bars, horizontal or vertical, any day. The only reason that the widescreen format came into existence is because people wanted to see films in the correct aspect ratio so that they didn't miss anything, yet most people with widescreen TVs permanently stretch or zoom the images so it seems quite pointless. Anyway, turn the lights off and enjoy the film at the correct aspect ratio. If the lights are off you shouldn't notice that you aren't filling your screen.
Eugenia wrote re: What Happened to Dual Sided DVD's?
on Sun, Jan 8 2006 7:00 AM
I also prefer 16:9 compared to 4:3. Jayson, put some money aside and buy a good HDTV with lots of HDMI inputs. :) Additionally, there was only one hollywood studio that was releasing DVD movies in both 4:3 and 16:9 on the SAME disk (can't remember which one it is). All the other companies were releasing multiple DVD versions. Maybe that company doesn't do it anymore like that. Maybe DVD burning these days is CHEAPER to do so in multiple disks rather than having a robot to change the DISK to the other side and have SPECIAL hardware to burn the other side. My guess is that there are economical reasons today for this.
Jayson Knight wrote re: What Happened to Dual Sided DVD's?
on Sun, Jan 8 2006 10:26 AM
@Brendan: Perhaps you misread the post b/c I completely agree with you! The 2 points I was trying to make were that A) I miss the dual sided discs which made everyone happy, and B) why does Blockbuster (the one's here at least) only carry widescreen format these days? Trust me, I love widescreen much more than 4:3, but my TV is 4:3 therefore I want my movies to be 4:3 as well. @Eugenia: Again I agree...I much prefer 16:9 over 4:3, but as my TV is 4:3 I want 4:3 DVD's :-). At the time I bought my HDTV 2.5 years ago, it was pretty much top of the line in its class (36" Sony Trinitron); no HDMI though. And I think you nailed it (as I mentioned in my post), more than likely there were economical reasons as to why they stopped. It really was a great idea though, and gave everyone the best of both worlds. Regardless, the next TV will more than likely be 16:9, and must have HDMI (which is a godsend).
Brendan wrote re: What Happened to Dual Sided DVD's?
on Sun, Jan 8 2006 6:57 PM
I just thought that I'd add that I have a few of those discs where you can choose widescreen or 4:3 depending on which side you put in and I always choose widescreen. However, my TV is 4:3. It does have a true widescreen mode on it where it plays the image at full resolution and vertically compresses it to 16:9 so that you don't lose any detail, but my previous TV didn't and I still chose widescreen. Personally, I'm not concerned whether or not the picture fills the screen horizontally and vertically, but it must be at the correct aspect ratio and I must see the full image. I know that many people have many varying opinions on this one though. I also read somewhere that it's cheaper to produce two single sided discs than one double sided disc, which is why many single sided two disc sets now exist.

Add a Comment

(optional)  
(optional)
(required)  
Remember Me?

Copyright © :: JaysonKnight.com
External Content © :: Respective Authors

Terms of Service/Privacy Policy